Ethical Clearance and Research Ethics Policy

Reog: Journal of Ecoethnoscience Education requires research involving human participants, animals, personal information, or other ethically sensitive subjects to be conducted in accordance with applicable ethical principles, institutional requirements, and relevant regulations.

Ethical Approval

Research involving human participants and/or animals must obtain appropriate ethical approval from an Institutional Review Board, Research Ethics Committee, or other authorized ethics committee, where such approval is required by the nature of the research, institutional requirements, or applicable regulations.

Required ethical approval must be obtained before undertaking the research activities that require such approval. Authors must clearly report the relevant ethical approval information in the manuscript, including the name of the approving ethics committee or institution, the ethical approval or Ethical Clearance number, and the year of issuance.

Low or Negligible Risk Research

For research classified as low or negligible risk, Reog may accept an Author statement declaring compliance with ethical requirements (ethical self-declaration) in place of an Ethical Clearance document for article reporting purposes, following assessment and approval by the Peer Reviewer(s) and/or Editorial Team.

The declaration must accurately reflect the circumstances of the research and describe the ethical safeguards implemented. Authors may be asked to explain the basis for the risk classification, the procedures for obtaining participant consent, and the measures taken to protect privacy and confidentiality.

Where Authors state that formal Ethical Clearance was not required under institutional requirements, they must be able to explain and substantiate the basis for that statement.

An ethical self-declaration does not override any requirement to obtain ethical approval imposed by an institution or applicable regulations. Classifying a study as low or negligible risk does not automatically guarantee that Reog will accept the declaration.

Research in Educational and Community Settings

For research conducted in schools, higher education institutions, communities, or other organizations, Authors must obtain appropriate site or institutional permission where required.

Such permission authorizes access to the setting and the conduct of the research. Permission from a school, institution, community leader, or other gatekeeper does not replace required ethical approval or individual participant consent.

Where Authors also serve as teachers, lecturers, supervisors, or persons holding authority over participants, they must manage potential pressure arising from these relationships and ensure that participation is voluntary. Refusing or discontinuing research participation must not adversely affect participants’ grades, access to education or services, or academic and professional relationships.

Participant Consent and Protection

Authors must obtain appropriate informed consent in accordance with the nature of the research and applicable requirements. Information about the research purpose, activities, use of data, foreseeable risks, and participant rights must be communicated in language that participants can understand.

For research involving children or individuals who cannot independently provide valid consent, Authors must obtain permission from a parent or legally authorized representative and seek the participant’s agreement, including children’s assent where appropriate to their age and capacity, in accordance with applicable requirements.

Where consent requirements are waived or consent procedures are modified, Authors must explain the basis and process used, including authorization from the relevant body where required.

Participation must be voluntary. Participants must be informed of their right to decline or discontinue participation without penalty or inappropriate disadvantage, including any applicable conditions or limitations concerning withdrawal of their data.

Local Knowledge and Cultural Sensitivity

Research involving local, traditional, or Indigenous knowledge must respect the dignity, cultural values, customary practices, and relevant rights of the individuals and communities concerned.

Authors must explain the intended use and publication of knowledge shared by participants and obtain appropriate consent or authorization where required. Permission to access a community does not automatically authorize the recording, disclosure, or publication of restricted, sacred, confidential, or culturally sensitive knowledge.

Authors must accurately represent community knowledge and practices, acknowledge contributions appropriately, and avoid reporting that stigmatizes communities or misrepresents their perspectives. Where relevant, arrangements concerning attribution, anonymity, access restrictions, and the sharing of research outcomes should be discussed with participants or appropriate community representatives.

Ethical Statements in the Manuscript

Ethical approval information or an ethical self-declaration must be clearly reported in the manuscript, preferably in the Methods section under Ethical Considerations, and must be consistent with the Declaration of Ethics in the latest official Reog Manuscript Templates.

This information must remain available in the published article, rather than appearing only in supporting submission documents.

Authors may use the following examples, adapting them to accurately reflect the circumstances of their research.

Example 1: Research with Ethical Clearance

Ethical approval for this study was obtained from the [Name of Ethics Committee/Institution], Ethical Clearance No. [number/year]. All procedures involving research participants were conducted in accordance with the approved ethical protocol, and informed consent was obtained where applicable.

Example 2: Low or Negligible Risk Research without Formal Ethical Clearance

The authors declare that this study was classified as low or negligible risk and did not require formal Ethical Clearance under the applicable institutional requirements. Permission to conduct the research was obtained from the relevant school/institution, and appropriate ethical safeguards, including voluntary participation, consent where applicable, and protection of participant confidentiality, were implemented.

These examples do not automatically apply to every study. Authors must adapt information about ethical approval, institutional requirements, research permission, and participant protection to reflect facts that can be substantiated. References to permission from a school, institution, or community must be included only where such permission was actually obtained.

The phrase “consent where applicable” does not remove any requirement to obtain participant consent or permission from a parent or legally authorized representative. Using the example self-declaration does not itself constitute Reog’s approval of its adequacy; assessment and approval take place during the editorial process.

For research that does not involve human participants, animals, or personal data requiring ethical review, Authors may state that ethical approval is not applicable, explaining the reason in relation to the research design and data sources.

Privacy and Identifiable Materials

Authors must protect participant privacy, confidentiality, and other relevant rights throughout data collection, storage, use, sharing, and publication.

Consent to participate in research must be distinguished from consent to publish identifiable materials. Publication of photographs, videos, quotations, personal information, or other materials that could identify an individual must be covered by appropriate consent for publication from that individual or, where required, a parent or legally authorized representative.

When identification is not necessary for the scholarly purpose of the manuscript, identifying information must be removed, anonymized, or appropriately obscured, for example by blurring faces, masking names or identification numbers, or cropping images. Authors must also consider whether individuals could be identified through captions or contextual information.

Any modification for privacy protection must not alter or misrepresent information relevant to the scholarly or scientific interpretation of the material.

Author and Editorial Responsibility

Every manuscript must comply with the Declaration of Ethics in the latest official Reog Manuscript Templates and the ethical provisions of the Statement of Manuscript Authenticity.

Authors remain responsible for the accuracy and authenticity of all ethical information, declarations, and documents provided. Reog may request evidence of Ethical Clearance, screening or exemption determinations, institutional provisions supporting the Authors’ statements, site or institutional permission, documentation of participant consent, ethical self-declarations, or other relevant documentation when necessary.

Ethical self-declarations are assessed and approved by the Peer Reviewer(s) and/or Editorial Team based on the nature of the research, its level of risk, and the reported participant safeguards. The assessment and approval are documented in the editorial system.

Incomplete ethical reporting may be returned to Authors for correction or clarification. Where required ethical approval was not obtained before the research activities requiring it, adding a declaration at submission does not replace that prior approval.

Manuscripts with inadequate ethical information or safeguards may be suspended from editorial processing or rejected. Ethical concerns identified after publication will be handled in accordance with the Reog Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement and, where applicable, the Research Misconduct and Post-Publication Policy.

Policy Review and Updates

This policy may be reviewed and updated periodically or whenever necessary to reflect developments in research and publication ethics, scientific journal accreditation requirements, applicable regulations, and the Editorial Team’s evaluation of its implementation.

Updates will be announced on the official Reog website, indicating the date of the update and, where necessary, transitional arrangements. Policy review does not diminish the responsibility of Authors and the Editorial Team to address ethical concerns involving manuscripts under consideration or articles already published.

References

This policy has been developed with reference to the following provisions and guidelines, taking account of their respective scope and applicability:

  1. Directorate General of Science and Technology. (2026). Decision of the Director General of Science and Technology No. 374/DST/D.D1/HM.01.01/2026 concerning Technical Guidelines for Scientific Journal Accreditation (Petunjuk Teknis Akreditasi Jurnal Ilmiah), particularly Section H.2 on the availability of ethical approval information (Ethical Clearance).

  2. National Research and Innovation Agency of Indonesia (BRIN). (2022). BRIN Regulation No. 22 of 2022 concerning Research Ethical Clearance (Klirens Etik Riset).

  3. British Educational Research Association. (2024). Ethical Guidelines for Educational Research, Fifth Edition.

  4. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Ethical Oversight, addressing ethical oversight in research and publication, including consent for publication, protection of vulnerable populations, and handling confidential data.

International guidelines inform relevant ethical practices while taking account of disciplinary standards, institutional requirements, and applicable regulations in the jurisdiction where the research is conducted.